Hundreds of Polish judges dressed in formal black robes marched in Warsaw on Saturday to protest a draft law aimed at punishing justices who question the government’s controversial court reforms. Senior judges from nearly all European Union member states joined the protest : worldnews


Disc:I took half on this protest. I am a lawyer

How Regulation and Justice, the ruling social gathering in Poland, is destroying democracy.

Half 1/four


The present authorities is destroying the nation from inside-out with its nepotism, spiritual zeal, communistic techniques, social packages and funding verge organizations (or trolls). I’m not an English native speaker so apologies for my errors.

EDIT: The under remark can be in a medium article format

A few months in the past, I created a 100 pages+ Wikia simply earlier than the polish elections in October 2019 to point out the magnitude of this “mafia”. It has all of the sources and movie or video proofs. Solely in Polish however you should utilize Google translator.


Moreover, my web site was used as a template for the primary opposition (PO) web site.

PIS staffed each single courtroom with its personal folks (ending the impartiality of judges). The very aggressive social 500+ program elevated the job inactivity of Poles to 48% (48% of in a position 16+ Polish residents aren’t learning nor working and aren’t trying to find work – and that’s why they don’t seem to be within the unemployment stats class). Furthermore, the Well being care system is the final on the EU rating, we don’t have any R&D and our navy relies round a few F16 and 40 years outdated T-72 tanks. There’s no fleet, the navy colleges underwent a purge of generals ( a pair dozen of them gave their resignation once they needed to get orders from a 24 years outdated pharmacian with out diploma). The corruption and nepotism is rampant, greater than 1000 members of the family and pals are in public corporations or in several Ministries. Polish PIS excessive rating politicians are additionally earning profits along with pimps and the mafia. They’re additionally giving hundreds of thousands of euros from public cash to the Catholic Church. They’re paying trolls to spew hate on Fb, by way of Whatsapp and on the net. A few of them are hiding and never prosecuting pedophiles within the Catholic Church. I imply, to not diminish Trump’s “awesomness” however think about if the WHOLE republican social gathering within the US was Trump-like. Shady offers, household within the govt, creating discord, staffing courts with their very own judges. As a lawyer, as an individual that studied, I’m simply mortified. Learn the under to know, albeit 1/10, crucial scandals.

Acronyms and most important characters:

  • PIS- present govt, Regulation and Justice, a Far proper social gathering with socialist packages. Majority in Parliament and the President is from PIS

  • PO- Civil Platform, most important opposition, middle. Majority in Senate,

  • J. Kaczynski, PIS chief, Twin brother of the lifeless Polish president

  • Z. Ziobro, Common Prosecutor and Minister of Justice. PIS

  • M. Banas, Head of the Supreme Audit workplace. PIS

  • M. Morawiecki, Prime minister. PIS

  • T. Rydzyk Roman Catholic priest and Redemptorist, founder and director of the conservative Radio Maryja station and television TRWAM

  • J. Kurski, chairman of the Polish nationwide state broadcaster TVP. PIS

  • A. Duda, President. PIS

  • M. Kuchcinski, ex-Marshal of the decrease home. PIS

  • B. Szydlo, ex-prime minister. PIS

Destruction of the rule of legislation.

Some passages under are taken from this pdf

No member state within the historical past of the EU has ever gone as far in subjugating its courts to govt management as the present Polish authorities. The Polish case has turn into a take a look at whether or not it’s doable to create a Soviet-style justice system in an EU member state; a system the place the management of courts, prosecutors and judges lies with the manager and a single social gathering.

Too few Europeans are conscious of the depth of this disaster. Throughout Europe, nationwide courts recognise the judgements of courts in different member states, whether or not these contain industrial legislation, the European arrest warrant or baby custody. Judges should assume that courts throughout the EU function in accordance with frequent values and ideas set out within the European Union Treaty and in its Constitution of Elementary Rights. As soon as judges throughout the EU have purpose to doubt whether or not courts in any member state present efficient judicial safety, the authorized order on which the EU rests collapses.

Freedom home – How PIS captured Poland’s Courts

Constitutional Tribunal adjustments

All of it started with the constitutional disaster 4 years in the past. Constitutional disaster and the destruction of the rule of legislation In 2015, parliament modified the legislation on the Constitutional Tribunal, which guidelines on the constitutionality of laws. The adjustments allowed them to annul the nominations of three judges made by the earlier parliament and appoint their very own. It shortened the phrases of the tribunal’s president and vice-president from 9 to a few years. The tribunal dominated the transfer unconstitutional in an open rise up, however the dispute stays unresolved. Julia Przylebska – was illegally named the president of the Tribunal courtroom by the president.

There’s an excessive amount of to explain. For additional information please go to the hyperlink. It’s a tremendous abstract of the entire ordeal. timeline and one other Nice freedomhouse report.

Supreme Court docket adjustments

The European Fee, the EU’s govt arm, mentioned one of the crucial controversial reforms was to do with the Supreme courtroom, which, amongst different duties, is accountable for confirming election outcomes. The thought was to decrease the age of retirement for Supreme Court docket justices from 70 to 65, however enable the Polish president to grant a five-year extension to whomever they deemed worthy. In 2019, the European Court docket of Justice (ECJ) — the EU’s highest courtroom —dominated this was unlawful, after an interim choice ordered 20 already-sacked judges be reinstated. In fact, PIS selected 2 new Constitutional judges, A politician Pawlowicz with communistic previous and Piotrowicz, additionally a politician and a prosecutor that was an lively communist in the course of the 80 that prosecuted Solidarnosc. Each of them are above 65 years outdated.

Peculiar courtroom judges

There have been additionally strikes to strive an identical tactic within the common courtroom system for judges and public prosecutors, reducing the age of retirement for girls to 60 and for males to 65, down from the present 67. Beneath the reforms the justice minister, who’s appointed by the ruling social gathering, would have the ability to increase a choose’s time period. The legal guidelines have been considerably adjusted after strain from the European Fee, however in November 2019 the ECJ shot down these legal guidelines, too, citing gender discrimination and political affect over the judiciary.

Disciplinary measures for judges

One other PiS addition allowed judges to be investigated and sanctioned for his or her courtroom rulings. The disciplinary hearings and procedures have been to be carried out by judges chosen by way of parliament. These reforms have been criticized by the European Fee as a result of “judges aren’t insulated from political management and thus judicial independence is violated.” The fee introduced authorized motion towards Poland on this matter in October 2019.

Nationwide Council of the judiciary takeover

In 2017 PiS remodelled the Nationwide Council of the Judiciary, which selects candidates for appointment as judges by the President of the Republic. This allowed it, within the brief time period, to manage appointments to the Supreme Court docket – together with to a newly created Disciplinary Chamber, which hears disciplinary circumstances towards judges, and to a brand new Extraordinary Appeals Chamber, which adjudicates on electoral points. Over time PiS’ take-over of the Nationwide Judicial Council permits it to reshape the whole thing of the judiciary. Fifteen of the 25 members of the Nationwide Council of the Judiciary have been beforehand elected by judges themselves, as is frequent follow throughout Europe for such our bodies. These fifteen judges are actually elected by the bulk within the Sejm, the decrease chamber of the Polish parliament. The opposite ten members of the Nationwide Council of the Judiciary are: 4 members from the Sejm itself (all 4 members of PiS), two members from the Senate, one consultant of the President of the Republic, the Minister of Justice, the president of the Supreme Court docket and the president of the Supreme Administrative Court docket. In whole 23 of the 25 positions are instantly appointed by political authorities.

After the election of the brand new KRS, a publication of the record with the names of judges declaring their assist for particular candidates was refused. The Supreme Administrative Court docket dominated that these names should be disclosed. Nonetheless, the Chancellery of the Sejm has but to hold out the NSA’s ruling. The Constitutional Tribunal (TK) and the President of the Private Information Safety Workplace have been roped into guarding the key. KRS destruction

Restructuring the courts

Forward of the 2019 election, the PiS proposed restructuring the courtroom system. The justice minister mentioned the nation had 4 ranges of courts that could possibly be decreased to a few. Critics mentioned this might enable the federal government to reappoint most judges and eliminate undesirable ones by means of compelled retirement or by sending them to distance appointments.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here